Let’s Talk About Co-ops

Let’s Talk About Co-ops | The Dalton Firm Insights

Co-ops are an attractive option for many first-time homebuyers because they tend to be more affordable than a condo or a house, but why? What does it mean to “own” a co-op? “Co-op” is short for Cooperative. When you buy a co-op, you are buying shares in a corporation that owns the building. Even though a co-op listing advertises a specific apartment, the buyer is purchasing shares. Just like you can buy 100 shares of Tesla, you can buy 100 shares of 123 Broadway Corporation. And just like you can lose your shirt in the stock market, you can lose your shirt buying shares in the wrong co-op.

When we receive a co-op contract, the phone immediately rings, and the listing agent wants to know when the buyer is signing. We in turn, immediately advise that we requested the last two years of financials and offering plan and must review prior to having our client sign the contract. We are not just being annoying lawyers. We want to make sure our client isn’t buying a one-way ticket aboard a sinking ship. We are looking to see if the corporation is healthy. What liabilities does it have, what major capital improvement are on the horizon, how much reserve does the corporation have? In other words, does the future of the corporation look bright or grim?

I grew up in a co-op in Rego Park, Queens called “Anita Terrace” and I can tell you from personal experience, it is imperative to know what you are getting into. In 2004, the co-op I grew up in was facing bankruptcy and liquidation. The building was in disrepair, and there were no funds for necessary maintenance. My parents had invested every hard-earned dime into this apartment, and nearly lost everything they had worked so hard to build. I was in High School at the time so I did not fully understand the gravity of what was happening. I stumbled across this article today, in researching what exactly happened at Anita Terrace. https://qns.com/2004/02/bankrupt-promises/ Crazy enough, the article is about my parents! “Janek and Sal Babek” are my mom and stepdad. My mom goes by “Janet” but other than the typo in her name, this article is a time capsule from my past.

Anita Terrace Cooperative was on the verge of being sold to an outside developer and becoming a rental development. If an agreement were not reached by the June 30th, 2004 deadline set by the bankruptcy court, resident shareholders like my parents would have become tenants rather than owners. At the same time, they would have remained personally liable for paying off mortgages on apartments they would no longer own. In the end (literally within hours of the bankruptcy), Pinnacle Group, led by Joel Weiner, agreed to purchase 238 sponsor- owned apartments in the complex for $13.5 million, much of which was to be used to make repairs and renovations to the property. In addition to purchasing apartments, Pinnacle also provided the cooperative with a new $30-million mortgage. In return, Pinnacle got a 99-year lease on the garage and the professional space owned by the cooperative.

Thankfully this story had a happy ending for my family, and they were able to eventually sell their co-op and move on. It is an important lesson however, to know what you’re buying, and have an experienced real estate attorney on your side.

This article is general information, not legal advice for your situation. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

The Dalton Firm, P.C.

Have a question about your situation?

Long Island real estate and estate planning, handled personally by attorney Marianna Dalton, admitted in New York since 2011. Flat fees, and a reply within one business day.